A Quick Primer to Workplace Pensions
What is a Workplace Pension?
A workplace pension is a retirement savings scheme arranged by your employer to help you build a pension pot for when you retire. If you are employed and meet the eligibility criteria, you are automatically enrolled into a workplace pension under the UK’s auto-enrolment rules. Your employer must contribute to your pension, and you will also make contributions from your salary, often with tax relief applied.
However, workplace pensions come in two main types: Defined Contribution (DC) pensions and Defined Benefit (DB) pensions. Let’s dive in to see the differences and compare and contrast each one.
Defined Contribution (DC) vs. Defined Benefit (DB) Workplace Pensions Explained
1. What is a Defined Contribution (DC) Pension?
A Defined Contribution workplace pension is based on how much you and your employer contribute over time. Your pension savings are invested, and the final amount you receive at retirement depends on investment performance.
How DC Pensions Work:
- You and your employer contribute a percentage of your salary into your pension pot.
- The contributions are invested in funds chosen by you or your pension provider.
- Your final pension pot depends on contributions made and investment growth.
- When you retire, you can withdraw the pension as a lump sum, through drawdown, or buy an annuity for guaranteed income.
How DC Pensions Are Calculated:
- Contributions: A percentage of your salary is deducted each month, typically 5% from you and 3% from your employer (minimum auto-enrolment contributions).
- Investment Growth: Your pension provider invests your contributions, and the pot grows over time.
- Charges: Some providers deduct management fees, which impact the final value.
- Retirement Age: Your pot is accessible from age 55 (rising to 57 in 2028), and the final value depends on market performance.
Key Features of DC Pensions:
✔ More flexibility in investment choices.
✔ Final pension amount depends on market performance.
✔ Withdrawals available from age 55.
✔ Can transfer to a new employer’s pension scheme.
2. What is a Defined Benefit (DB) Pension?
A Defined Benefit workplace pension (also called a Final Salary or Career Average pension) guarantees a fixed income for life after retirement (sounds like a dream…) based on your salary and length of service.
How DB Pensions Work:
- Your employer makes contributions to a pension fund, but you may also contribute.
- The pension amount is determined by your salary and years of service.
- Instead of relying on investment growth, your employer guarantees a fixed retirement income.
- Payments are usually indexed to inflation to maintain value over time.
How DB Pensions Are Calculated:
- Final Salary Formula: Usually based on a percentage of your final salary multiplied by years of service.
- Example: A DB pension might offer 1/60th of your final salary per year worked.
- If you worked for 30 years and your final salary was £40,000, you’d receive: (30/60) × £40,000 = £20,000 per year in retirement.
- Career Average Earnings Formula: Uses your average salary over your career instead of final salary.
- Inflation Protection: Many DB pensions may increase payments yearly to match inflation.
Key Features of DB Pensions:
✔ Provides a guaranteed retirement income.
✔ Often inflation-proof.
✔ No investment risk for the employee.
✔ Difficult to transfer into a DC scheme (requires advice if over £30,000).
✔ Cannot be withdrawn early like DC pensions.
Can You Withdraw a Workplace Pension Early?
- Defined Contribution (DC) Pensions: You can withdraw from age 55 (rising to 57 in 2028). The first 25% is tax-free, and the rest is taxed as income.
- Defined Benefit (DB) Pensions: You cannot withdraw as a lump sum before retirement unless you transfer it to a DC scheme.
- Early Withdrawal Risks: Taking money too early reduces retirement income and can result in higher taxes.
Transferring a Workplace Pension
If you change jobs, your workplace pension does not automatically move with you. Here’s how transfers work:
✔ Defined Contribution Pensions: You can leave it where it is, transfer it to your new employer’s scheme, or combine it with a private pension (e.g., a SIPP).
✔ Defined Benefit Pensions: Transferring out of a DB scheme is difficult and usually not recommended unless you seek financial advice (required if transferring over £30,000).
✔ Self-Employed Transfers: If you become self-employed, you can move your pension into a SIPP (Self-Invested Personal Pension) to continue saving.
How to Transfer a Workplace Pension from Your Last Employer:
- Check Your Pension Details: Contact your old employer or pension provider to check your balance and any transfer restrictions.
- Compare Pension Providers: If moving to a new employer’s scheme or private pension, research fees, investment options, and flexibility.
- Request a Transfer Form: Your current pension provider will provide paperwork to initiate the transfer.
- Submit Transfer Request: Fill out the forms with your new provider and ensure a smooth transition.
- Monitor the Transfer: Transfers typically take 2-12 weeks. Ensure funds arrive safely in your new pension.
Workplace Pensions for the Self-Employed
If you are self-employed, you will not have access to an employer-sponsored workplace pension, but you can set up your own pension scheme:
How to Set Up a Workplace-Style Pension If You Are Self-Employed
- Choose a Pension Type:
- Self-Invested Personal Pension (SIPP) – Ideal if you want full control over investments.
- Personal Pension – A simpler, managed pension scheme with lower involvement.
- Stakeholder Pension – A low-cost, flexible option with government-mandated caps on fees.
- Find a Provider:
- Popular providers include Vanguard, Hargreaves Lansdown, AJ Bell, and Fidelity.
- Make Contributions:
- Self-employed individuals must contribute independently.
- You get tax relief on contributions up to 100% of your earnings (capped at £60,000 per year).
- Setting Up a Pension Through a Limited Company:
- If you run your own company, you can set up a Company Director’s Pension.
- Your business can contribute to your pension, reducing corporation tax.
- Contributions from your company do not count towards your personal annual allowance, making this a tax-efficient option.
- Continue National Insurance Contributions (NICs):
- Keep paying NICs to ensure you qualify for the State Pension.
If you’re self-employed, starting a pension sooner rather than later is essential since you won’t receive employer contributions.
Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Workplace Pension Strategy
A workplace pension is a crucial part of retirement planning, whether through a Defined Contribution or Defined Benefit scheme.
- DC pensions offer flexibility but depend on market performance.
- DB pensions provide guaranteed income but are harder to transfer.
- If you change jobs, you may need to consolidate pensions over time.
- If you become self-employed, setting up a private pension is key to ensuring a secure retirement.
Understanding your workplace pension options now can help you make smarter financial decisions for the future. If unsure, consider speaking to a pension advisor to tailor a plan to your needs. On the plus side, you can always use a Pension Drawdown Calculator to also see how much you could be saving / earning in retirement.
- What is the MPAA Rule in Pension Drawdown? - February 24, 2025
- How an Annuity Impacts Your Pension Drawdown - February 7, 2025
- Different Types of Pensions: SIPP vs Other Pension Options - February 5, 2025
Indira is a seasoned expert when it comes to pensions and retirement savings. Having advised several HNW retirees in her former life as a financial advisor, she now works as an independent advisor within the personal finance space and contributes to Pension Drawdown Calculator articles. Her work has been featured in Forbes, the Telegraph, among others.
4 Responses